THE NO-COST SOLUTION TO OVER-CROWDED PUBLIC SCHOOLS
(Chuck Muth) - I am so sick of hearing the Clark County school district and
education monopolists whine about supposed over-crowding in public
schools.The latest from Monday’sLas Vegas Review-Journal…
“With 319,072 students there are 61 schools that are overcrowded and 21
schools that face possible rezoning due to overcrowding in the nation’s fifth
largest school district, he said.(Superintendent Pat) Skorkowsky said the district could build 26 new
elementary schools and still have overcrowding issues.”
This issue is so easy, fast and cost-free to fix it ain’t
Let’s say you have a school that is overcrowded by 500
students.Simple.Offer 500 parents $5,000 vouchers if they
will remove their child from the overcrowded public school and enroll him or
her in a private school of the parents’ choice.
Since the school district gets more than $5,000 per child as
is, they would actually have money left over to spend on the remaining kids in the
school that is no longer over-crowded thanks to kids leaving.
And by the way, this is not some unprecedented idea.This is something that has already been implemented
just in Douglas County, Colorado.
“Under the program,” reports the Education Policy Center, “scholarship
recipients could receive as much as 75 percent of state per-pupil funding
(approximately $4,600 in 2011-12, just over $5,000 in 2014-15) or the amount of
nonpublic school tuition, whichever was less. The Douglas County School
District was to issue quarterly checks payable to the parents of Choice
Scholarship recipients, which the parents then restrictively endorsed to the
participating nonpublic schools that accepted their students for enrollment.”
“But,” I hear the liberal defenders of the status quo bleat,
“there aren’t enough private schools to accommodate the kids who would be
leaving the public school.”
Such an objection betrays a total lack of understanding of how
the free market works!
I GUARANTEE you that if 500 parents suddenly started
waving $5,000 voucher/scholarship checks around in the air, the private sector
would find room to accommodate them.
The 500 seats may not be in what is considered a “normal”
school – the school might be set up in a vacant building or strip mall - but
the seats WILL be found and the kids WILL get an excellent
And as for the silly complaint that vouchers will result in
the “cream of the crop” students leaving the public schools for private schools…so
The public schools are already tasked with the
responsibility of teaching students with various learning challenges.Under my plan, those same schools and same
teachers will be able to devote MORE personal attention to those
students who need extra help thanks to the smaller class size!
So let it be written; so let it be done.
And while we’re on this subject of education and school
choice during School Choice Week…
In his State of the State address, Gov. Brian Sandoval (R&R-Advertising) proposed a laundry list of new
feel-good/cost-a-lot education spending programs.Some $800 million worth of tax dollars to be
flushed down the failure factory toilets.
Now here’s the thing…
In his first four years in office, Sandoval has hired or
appointed only one readily identifiable movement conservative.That would be Dr. Jim Guthrie as Superintendent of Public Instruction for the Nevada
Department of Education.
Guthrie was a true, bona fide, card-carrying conservative education
Indeed, he had this radical idea that the way to fix our
lousy public schools in Nevada wasn’t to simply dump more money into the
system, but to implement various real education reforms directed at parental
choice and holding teachers more accountable.
As such, Sandoval fired Guthrie after only about one year on
Or I guess the official line was that Guthrie was allowed to
resign against his will.Yeah, that’s
In any event, it’s now clear that Sandoval only wants to get
hosannas from liberals for spending more money on education rather than pushing
for true reforms that would actually fix education and help our children.
And that’s why he canned Guthrie and installed one of his
tax-and-spend cronies in the job instead.
Personnel is policy.
FAMOUS LAST WORDS
“Gov. Brian Sandoval is shirking his responsibility to
reform a public school system that is staggering under a top-heavy layer of
overpaid, nonteaching bureaucrats. He is instead proposing huge new tax hikes
to fund his vanity education programs, none of which will improve learning.
“Worse, Gov. Sandoval and his political cronies have been
working with Republicans-in-name-only to interfere with the Nevada Assembly
leadership selection process. Maybe you thought the governor’s job-killing
tax-and-spend initiatives would come under cross-examination in the crucible of
the new Republican-controlled Legislature. Sorry, the fix is in. After the
vote-buying and arm-twisting, it’s doubtful there are enough ‘nays’ to stop
“There are plans afoot to recall Republican lawmakers who
betray their voters and their party’s core principles to vote with Democrats to
hike taxes. Your only hope to avoid getting fleeced is to tell Republican
legislators that you’ll hold them to their party’s principles and no-new-taxes
- Lynn Muzzy of Minden, Las Vegas Review-Journal, 1/27/15
You can read this column online, as well as access archives of past Muth's Truths columns by clicking here...